AI-ENC vs ENC vs PNC: Which Noise Cancellation is Better?
When choosing earbuds or headsets, understanding the type of noise cancellation is crucial. Each technology—AI-ENC, ENC, and PNC—works differently and serves distinct purposes based on use case, environment, and performance requirements.
Types of Noise Cancellation Technologies
-
Passive Noise Cancellation (PNC)
PNC relies on physical barriers—like earbud tips and over-ear padding—to block out ambient noise. It doesn’t involve any electronic processing.
- Mechanism: Creates a seal in or around the ear to physically block outside sound.
- Characteristics:
- Noise Reduction Level: Moderate, mainly in high-frequency ranges.
- Power Use: No battery or processing required.
- Consideration: Most effective when combined with a snug fit and high-quality materials.
-
Environmental Noise Cancellation (ENC)
ENC focuses on reducing background noise picked up by microphones during calls. It's often used in TWS earbuds and headsets to improve voice clarity.
- Mechanism: Uses dual-mic arrays to detect external noise and isolate the speaker’s voice.
- Characteristics:
- Noise Reduction Level: Moderate, optimized for call clarity.
- Power Use: Minimal battery usage.
- Consideration: Does not actively reduce noise for the listener—only filters the mic input.
-
AI-Environmental Noise Cancellation (AI-ENC)
AI-ENC leverages machine learning algorithms to intelligently detect and suppress unwanted noise during calls and sometimes during media playback.
- Mechanism: Trained AI models process sound input in real-time, separating human voice from environmental noise.
- Characteristics:
- Noise Reduction Level: High, especially in dynamic and complex environments.
- Power Use: Moderate to high processing load.
- Consideration: Performance depends on the quality of the AI model and chip processing capabilities.
Comparison Table
Technology | Noise Reduction | Best For | Pros | Cons |
---|---|---|---|---|
PNC | Basic (Physical only) | Music listening, budget earbuds | Battery-free, no latency | Less effective in noisy environments |
ENC | Moderate (Voice isolation) | Voice calls | Improves call clarity, low power use | Doesn’t reduce noise for the listener |
AI-ENC | High (Adaptive and intelligent) | Business calls, travel, dynamic use | Superior background noise suppression | More battery consumption, dependent on AI quality |
Conclusion
If your priority is blocking environmental noise during calls, especially in unpredictable or loud settings, AI-ENC offers the best performance. For general voice call clarity in quieter environments, ENC suffices. For passive sound isolation and music listening, especially in-ear form factors, PNC is a reliable low-power choice.
For advanced AI-ENC audio components and consulting, explore the innovations at SPEAKER DRIVER™️.